Kentucky Craigslist Cat Killer Sentenced

Alex Phelps, 26, of Shepherdsville, KY, arrested as the Craigslist Cat Killer in January 2011, was sentenced on Friday, January 11. He was convicted in December after pleading guilty to eight counts of animal torture across Jefferson and Bullitt counties in Kentucky. Phelps was facing a possible 40 year sentence when he unexpectedly took a plea deal immediately before last month’s scheduled trail, just before jury selection. His attorneys were displeased with his decision, having planned an insanity defense for him.

Phelps presented himself as a mild mannered animal lover as he collected his victims from Craigslist, and his horrific killing spree is a primary reason why people are advised not to give their cats away on Craigslist. While charged in 8 torture, killing and dismemberment incidents, he admitted to 26 killings to authorities and is thought to have even more victims.

In keeping with the terms of the plea deal, Phelps received a 5 year sentence.

Earlier during the run of the case, authorities made public Phelps’ bizarre statements made during interviews, including that he found cats to be “fascinating” creatures who can sense electromagnetic activity and, as scientists begin to understand this, it could open the door to human telepathy.

Phelps said of his victims,”I didn’t mistreat them. They were not killed in an inhumane manner. They were put down. I didn’t want them to suffer. They were already neglected enough. He went on to describe his methods in a manner that reflects his interest in becoming a doctor. Most of the details of the case are too disturbing to be shared here. The killings were followed by mutilation.

Jason Knopp, who gave his cats to Phelps, testified at the sentencing hearing on Friday, saying “Those cats were companions to me when I was going through a really hard time in my life. I was in end-stage renal failure.” When Phelps got the Knopp cats off of Craigslist, Jason Knopp thought they were going to be in good hands. Instead, he testified, “I know that my cats were tortured and mutilated, that they died slow and painful deaths.”

Phelps tried to get out of his 5 year prison sentence in court on Friday, saying he was ashamed of his “monstrous” behavior, and the defense team pushed for counseling and probation. Phelps said, “I am sorry to the victims for the pain that I have caused them, for what I have put them through and for how long they went through it, and I am sorry to my family for what I put them through.” After sentencing, Kopp said “I am very pleased, I think justice has been done today.”

The judge stuck by the 5 year sentence. Pamela Rogers, KY state director of HSUS said she approved: “I think that it shows people that might have an indication that they might want to do something to an animal, that they will get punished. And that is one reason why we try to pass laws, we try to make sure they are enforced that the perpetrators for these kinds of crimes are going to pay.”

Phelps has served more than 450 days in jail, meaning he is already eligible for parole. There has been no word that we are aware of, whether parole will be allowed.

WDRB report on the sentencing hearing held Friday, January 11, 2013.
WDRB 41 Louisville – News, Weather, Sports Community

A 2011 report featureds a woman who gave her kittens to a young man representing himself as an animal lover. When news of the cat killer’s arrest broke, she realized he had given the kittens to killer Alex Phelps.

15 thoughts on “Kentucky Craigslist Cat Killer Sentenced”

  1. Why I wish Craigslist would be banned and removed from the internet. This is nothing but a place for murderers and people that have nothing else better to do with their life but intimidate and discriminate against is all it is fit for!!!!!

  2. His face and deed should be shown and known by all , especially to those who are eager to dump their pet. And 2013 is here ! We must keep him in mind always


  4. CL does help reuinite pets with owners when they go lost, so it’s not all bad. I recently found a sweet dog that I think was dumped on our street. I did put an ad on Craigslist for a found dog. But wouldn’t consider giving a pet away on there. I would rather network and find a friend or a friend of a friend. We did find a home for the dog using the friend of a friend method.

    Don’t throw the baby out with the bath water!

  5. a common misconception about this story is that he got unwanted animals or strays. that is far from the truth. these animals were loved and cared for, and the people who had them did not want to give them up but had to for various reason. they asked questions, they tried to do what they could to ensure that he was going to care for them. he said everything that he needed to say in order to come off as a person who would be a great caretaker. I wasnt even actively trying to rehome my cat, i hadnt posted any ads anywhere. he just knew that i was concerned abou the living situation for the cat because I talked about it several times when he was visiting my house. he offered to help me by providing a home where he would receive the veterinary care he needed and where no other cats lived and he woulfnt get picked on. I am a cautious person already and made it perfectly clear that he would have to call me if for ANY REASON he couldnt keep the cat or had issues because I didnt want him to end p somewhere unknown. HE promised and and told me all the things he was going to do for the cat and how he would care for it. a month later, Alex was arrested and I went to his home to confront his parents to find my cat and they claimed they had no idea where my cat was as they had not seen any cats.

  6. Just so everybody knows this psycho is getting out early in 2 weeks for good behavior….Our system is so messed up……don’t give your pets away!

Leave a Comment