Little Heart Kitten’s 12yr Old Killer Found Guilty But Justice Is Weakly Served

Life With Cats is reader-supported. We may earn a small commission through products purchased using links on this page.

A brutal case with a tiny victim, a young hero, and a young thug went to court yesterday and justice was weakly served.

Many readers will remember Little Heart, the tiny kitten beaten and abused at a Suffolk VA playground in broad daylight on Saturday, May 28, 2011. According to reports, Jamarea Mills and his brother were playing with a tiny 7 week old kitten when a bully came along and snatched the animal away from them.  A group of children then looked on helplessly as the 12 year old boy callously and viciously brutalized the kitten for fun. When the tormenter pulled out a pocket knife and announced that he was about to “cut” the kitten, 9 year old hero Jamarea  was compelled to act. He knocked the knife from the bully’s hands and the kitten was spared.

Jamarea and the other children carefully placed the kitten in a box to protect it from the elements in a gesture of respect, thinking it was dead. An Animal Control officer later came by, discovered the kitten was alive and took it to receive medical care and find protection at the local shelter. The kitten was initially determined to have a broken leg and bruised abdomen and lung but was expected to live and go to a good home.

Little Heart was rushed to the vet with breathing difficulties on the night of June 2, and died in the wee hours of the morning of Friday, June 3, the day he was supposed to go from foster care to his loving forever home.

After Little Heart’s death, the 12 year old killer’s charge was upgraded from a misdemeanor to felony animal cruelty when a necropsy verified that the kitten died as a result of  injuries received that day at the playground.

Unfortunately, a point of law caused the charge to be downgraded back to a misdemeanor. Felony animal cruelty charges in that jurisdiction are reserved for companion animals, and Little Heart was designated to be a stray at the time of the brutal assault. So, in the eyes of the law, because Little heart did not have a home and people to love him at the time of the attack, his death is considered a less terrible act.

The perpetrator’s case went to court yesterday, and thanks to good investigation by Suffolk animal control, and diligence on the part of the prosecutor, the12 year old, whose identity is protected, was found guilty of the misdemeanor charge. Punishment, if we can call it that, will be specified at a later date, but will likely be “some form of rehabilitation or counseling” according to a report in the Suffolk News Herald.

In a move we have seen elsewhere with female prosecutors, the prosecutor seems somewhat sympathetic to the psychopath who tortured tiny,  innocent Little Heart.  While Susan Walton says she and her office are pleased to have gotten a conviction,  she is quoted saying “To be that cruel, what concerns me is that you need to evaluate why that would happen and hopefully get him some help.” It is our opinion that society needs help in no longer being subjected to the perpetrator’s violent acts, and counseling will likely be of no use toward that end.

Ms. Walton praised the young witnesses, who were brave enough to come to court and stand their ground. Though the attacker denied his involvement, a 5 year old, an 8 year old, and two 9 year old all steadfastly kept to their original story, telling that the defendant committed the act.

The actual “punishment” will be handed down at a later date.

Brave and caring hero, Jamarea Mills

See more coverage at our index of Little Heart stories.


6 thoughts on “Little Heart Kitten’s 12yr Old Killer Found Guilty But Justice Is Weakly Served”

  1. Because an innocent animal has no home it is not treated to the same respect by the law as another living animal with a home. What a bunch of B.S. The judge needs a good swift kick in the a$$ for not having the heart to give that monster a stiff punishment. What is wrong with our world? Can’t people figure out that no matter the age of the monster committing the crime that it is still suppose to be a human and know rigth from wrong. The 12 yr. old monster pulled out a knife. No one can tell me that the idiot did not know that what he was doing was wrong. Oh well just another criminal society will have to deal with because the law won’t until it is too late! Oh wait a minute it is too late for the poor little innocent cat who lost its life!

  2. I agree with all these comments,i followed Little Hearts story from the very begining and shed quite a few tears over this little one.Im APPALLED at the outcome of this and as everyone has already said this kid is going to go on abuseing animals,and probly people too as he gets older.Yet again the laws or lack there of have let the animal down but done NOTHING to stop the offender.SICKENING!!!

  3. From a few states away, I am absolutely appalled at this – the whole thing from the 12 year old doing this, to Little Heart dying, then to the lame excuse for animal abuse laws in Virginia just horrifies me! I think the 12 year old’s name, his parent’s names and his address need to be made public due to the very real potential harm to the public and their animals. I have no tolerance for anyone, children or adults, who abuse animals – they are evil, soulless people that only mean harm to other living things on this planet!

Leave a Comment